Years before Team Angie vs. Team Jen, it was Team Lindsay vs. Team Hilary. In 2002, Lohan fought with Duff over Aaron Carter, who couldn't seem to choose between the stars. Two years later, Lohan took up arms again when she fought with Ashlee Simpson over Wilmer Valderrama (a feud which inspired Simpson's hit single "Boyfriend").
Photo By: Tommaso Boddi/WireImage.com; Jamie McCarthy/Getty Images; Jason LaVeris/FilmMagic