Despite low scores, Osmond and partner Jonathan Roberts made it to the Season 5 final, where their weird doll freestyle and score of 46 — almost 50 points fewer than the top two — ensured their elimination. Big bro Donny went on to win Season 9.
"Marie Osmond ... can't let Donny be ONLY winner!" — Steve Repsher
Photo Credits: Randy Shropshire/Getty Images; Sonja Flemming, CBS; Kevin Mazur, Getty Images for TNT; Michael Gladis; HBO; Gabe Ginsberg, WireImage; Frazer Harrison/Getty Images; Jenny Anderson/WireImage; Paul Archuleta, FilmMagic; Dan MacMedan, Getty Images