Sam has another vision that leads the brothers to Oklahoma, where they encounter a man who possesses the ability to make anyone do anything he wants, but there is a sinister element about him that Sam and Dean want to investigate. Andy: Gabriel Tigerman.
Sam and Dean investigate a series of bank robberies committed by unlikely suspects who then kill themselves, but autopsies reveal that in each case the thief had actually died days before the crime, pointing to a shape-shifter committing the thefts.
Action on the soundstage of a film studio's production of a ghost movie includes mysterious deaths, so Sam and Dean investigate, discovering a fatal flaw within the script. Brad: Gary Cole. Jay Wiley: Don Stark. Kendra: Alycia Purrott.
Sam and Dean come into possession of a rabbit's foot that belonged to their dad, but it's not necessarily good luck, because if it's lost, death follows within a week. Gordon: Sterling K. Brown. Bela Talbot: Lauren Cohan. Bobby: Jim Beaver.