Andrew Garcia, American Idol
It was tough for Andrew Garcia to overcome mixed criticism from the American Idol judging panel, the recently eliminated contestant says.
Read our American Idol recaps
Although Garcia wowed the judges during Hollywood Week with an acoustic cover of Paula Abdul's "Straight Up," he never seemed to find that same spark in his subsequent performances. Garcia says the advice of the judges — who seemed to always compare everything to the Abdul cover — wasn't making it any easier.
"I was just confused," Garcia tells TVGuide.com...
America spoke, and the judges intervened. That's right: The one-time-only judges' save was used. Ryan Seacrest promised some shocking results at the top of the show, and the promise was mostly fulfilled. So, who got a second chance? Let's find out...
Aaron Kelley, Katie Stevens
Offering a backstage look at the American Idol experience, Season 9 rolled on as the top 10 singers perform soul and R&B songs. There to guide the contestants was Usher, who despite sounding like a broken record, seemed genuinely committed to helping every singer squeeze the most out of his or her songs. In the end, one contestant finally stood out, one reclaimed former glory and one stumbled right out of the gate. Who impressed and who fell flat? Let's find out...