Usually by this point in the competition, the final four Idol contestants tend to leave judges (including Simon) wowed by their performances. Unfortunately for Jason Castro, that wasn't the case. The dread-head not only tanked by judges' standards with his first Bob Marley tune, "I Shot the Sheriff," but he forgot a chunk of lyrics in the refrain of his second choice, Bob Dylan's "Mr. Tambourine Man." Will America show him mercy?
- Gina DiNunno



Your take: Do you think Jason cracked under the pressure of being in the final four, or does it seem as though he's "given up" and is just phoning it in at this point?