Controversy Could Have Kiboshed Idol's Carly Smithson

What would Jesus do? Isn't that always the question? Who knows, he might have said, "My child, that was a little pitchy for me."

The New York Times speculates that the controversy surrounding "Jesus Christ Superstar," the movie theme song sung by Carly Smithson this week on American Idol, may have contributed to her ouster. She received the lowest number of votes among the six remaining contestants.

Since the movie's release 35 years ago, the song has come under scrutiny by Christians. Many believe it portrays Jesus as unsure of his role as a religious icon.

So, Idol followers, what do you think? Did Carly get caught up in controversy, or were there just simply five better performances than hers? - J.R. Whalen