4 of 18
Ben and Kate (Fox)
The Good: Nat Faxon and Dakota Johnson bring a lived-in realism to their sibling alter egos. Johnson, in particular, has been a real revelation, making Kate's smart awkwardness believable in a way that that of New Girl Jess isn't.
The Bad: Though everyone has had their moments of wackiness, the show can't let scene-stealers Tommy (Echo Kellum), BJ (Lucy Punch) and Maddie (Maggie Elizabeth Jones) run away with everything.