Tyler Blackburn, Ashley Benson

Ashley Benson and her Pretty Little Liars character Hanna have one major thing in common: their taste in guys.

"Caleb is definitely my type," she said when asked which of the PLL guys her high school self would want to date. "I like the grungy-looking guys and I love Johnny Depp, and he looks like Johnny Depp."

While Hanna and Caleb (played by Tyler Blackburn) have recently reconnected, Benson hints that there might be trouble to come in paradise. "After Tuesday's episode there's a change that happens for them — it's very emotional."

Bad news for "Haleb" fans? "Some might be disappointed," she adds.

See photos of Ashley Benson

TVGuide.com chatted with Benson at the signing of her Seventeen magazine cover where she shared some advice she wishes she had listened to when she was 17. "Be yourself," the 21-year-old actress said. "I tried to be like all of my friends and it didn't work out well. Now I'm finally comfortable being myself."

Editor-in-Chief Ann Shoket added that Benson was the perfect choice as a cover girl because she's "the coolest chick on the coolest show. She's exactly the kind of girl you would want to call up on a Saturday afternoon and say let's go shopping, let's talk about boys."

Watch a clip of Hanna and Caleb from Tuesday's episode airing at 8/7c on ABC Family.