Jake Johnson, Maria Thayer

The one that got away is coming back into Nick's life on New Girl.

Forgetting Sarah Marshall's Maria Thayer has been cast to play Nick's college girlfriend, Amelia, E! News reports. After breaking his heart back in the day, Amelia reemerges into Nick's life in the upcoming Halloween episode.

Get the scoop on the new season of New Girl and more returning shows!

Thayer also recently guest-starred on Louie and Harry's Law.

The new season of New Girl premieres on Tuesday, Sept. 25 with new episodes at 8/7c and 9/8c.

Are you excited to meet Nick's ex?