Jason Mesnick and Molly Malaney

Is the second time the charm?

Former Bachelor Jason Mesnick, who infamously dumped Melissa Rycroft for Molly Malaney on-air, has formally popped the question to the runner-up-turned-woman of his dreams, People reports.

Watch videos of Jason Mesnick

Mesnick proposed to Malaney Tuesday, who "giddily" accepted, during a trip to New Zealand. New Zealand, of course, was the locale of the Bachelor finale, where Mesnick originally sent Malaney packing and proposed to Rycroft. Mesnick and Malaney returned to the site so "Jason can do what he should have done the last time he was here, and ask Molly to marry him," a source tells the magazine.

Melissa Rycroft sets wedding date

Rycroft, who called Mesnick a "bastard" after he broke up with her on the After the Rose special, is engaged too: The Dancing with the Stars alum and Good Morning America correspondent will marry insurance agent Tye Strickland on Dec. 12.