Aaron Tviet and Emily Rose

Mike's double life is about to catch up with him on Graceland -- and we're not talking about his work with the FBI.

In this exclusive sneak peek from Wednesday's episode (10/9c, USA), Mike (Aaron Tveit) is nearly speechless when he finds his D.C. girlfriend (and FBI higher-up) Jessica (Emily Rose) downstairs in the house waiting to greet him.

Our favorite TV crime-solving duos

Their unplanned romantic reunion gets even more awkward when they're interrupted by Paige (Serinda Swan), aka the DEA agent Mike has been sleeping with ever since he returned to Southern California.

How does Mike handle it? Watch the exclusive video below to find out:

Graceland airs Wednesdays at 10/9c on USA. Who should Mike choose?