Steve Jones, Nicole Sherzinger, Simon Cowell, Paula Abdul and L.A. Reid

The anticipation finally is over. On Wednesday, Fox's The X Factor debuted, reuniting American Idol judges Simon Cowell and Paula Abdul. Was the competition show as exciting as you expected? Or is it just another singing reality series?

Vote: Which fall premieres won you over? Which flopped?

On ABC, Emily VanCamp returned to television with Revenge, a modern, soapy retelling of the literary classicThe Count of Monte Cristo. Are you hooked on the Hamptons-set mystery?

Vote now! And be sure to tell your friends and other fans to vote.

Check out all the familiar faces returning to TV this year

Check back to see what users think of your favorite — and least favorite — new shows for fall and the final rankings for the debuts.

When can you vote next? Here's a calendar to help you keep track.