Reid Rosenthal

TVGuide.com readers are hoping for what would be the most dramatic Bachelorette outcome ever: Jillian Harris choosing Reid Rosenthal, a bachelor she's already rejected.

Forty-one percent of more than 2,800 voters in an online poll want Rosenthal, the most recently jilted bachelor, to win Jillian's heart. The previews for the finale show him returning. But would she take him back over her two final two suitors?

Ed Swiderski, the businessman from Chicago who exited early on in The Bachelorette to keep his job, returned to fight for Jillian, and has garnered more than 28 percent of the votes cast.

Kiptyn Locke, the cute Californian, was a close third place with 26 percent of readers thinking he should receive the final rose.

Do you agree that Reid is the best choice?