The Bachelorette, Kiptyn and Reid

Jillian may have made up her mind, but TVGuide.com readers are torn between Bachelorette rejects Kiptyn Locke and Reid Rosenthal.

In a poll that asked users who they thought should be the next Bachelor, Kiptyn and Reid both nabbed 38 percent of the more than 3,000 votes cast. (Interestingly, in a poll launched before the final rose, the majority wanted Jillian to pick Reid.)

Twelve percent would like to see another Bachelorette beau assume the mantle, while the remaining 12 percent is ready for an unfamiliar face to be the next Bachelor — something that hasn't happened since Londoner Matt Grant looked for love in the spring of 2008.