Donny Osmond

Can Donny Osmond do what Marie couldn't and win Dancing with the Stars? Twenty-six percent of TVGuide.com voters think so.

In a poll that asked users to pick their early Season 9 frontrunner, Osmond emerged victorious, nabbing more than a quarter of the nearly 4,000 votes cast. Osmond's sister, Marie, finished in third place on the ABC hit's fifth season.

With 16 percent of the vote, Melissa Joan Hart is voters' second favorite to win, edging out Mya. The R&B singer/actress, who sang and danced in Chicago, garnered 13 percent.

Tied with 7 percent are singer Aaron Carter, Olympic gold medalist swimmer Natalie Coughlin and Iron Chef America's Chairman Mark Dacascos, who is also a trained martial artist.

Kathy Ireland, Michael Irvin and Chuck Liddell each earned 4 percent of the vote, followed by Kelly Osbourne with 3 percent, and former House majority leader Tom DeLay and Entourage's Debi Mazar tied with 2 percent.

Bringing up the rear with 1 percent each are Macy Gray, Joanna Krupa, Louie Vito and Ashley Hamilton, whose father, George, finished fifth on Season 2.